The election of AfD politician Tobias Rausch as Speaker of the Saxony Anhalt state parliament has raised questions over the four votes he received beyond the combined seats held by the AfD and BSW. Rausch was elected on Tuesday with 48 of the 82 votes cast. The AfD has 39 seats and the BSW five, giving the two parties 44 seats together. Because the ballot was secret, it is not known which lawmakers provided the additional support.
Of the 82 lawmakers present, 48 voted for Rausch, 29 voted against him and five abstained. One lawmaker was absent from the state parliament on Tuesday. The BSW had officially announced beforehand that it would support the AfD candidate. The SPD, Greens and Left, which each have eight lawmakers, had announced that they would vote against Rausch.
The CDU has 15 lawmakers in the state parliament. Its parliamentary group leadership had recommended before the vote that all 15 abstain. Apparently, only a few Christian Democrats followed that recommendation.
The voting figures do not establish which parties supplied the additional votes. While Rausch received four more votes than the AfD and BSW have seats together, the secret ballot means those votes cannot be assigned to specific lawmakers or parliamentary groups.
CDU Vice Chair and Federal Family Minister Karin Prien said it had not been established who voted for Rausch. She made clear, however, that if members of the CDU parliamentary group had supported him, this would be “completely unacceptable”. She referred to the CDU’s existing resolutions, including its position on voting for AfD motions.
CDU Secretary General Franziska Hoppermann called the election a “serious blow” for the party. She said supporting an extremist party or a government led by it was incompatible with CDU values. She also noted that the secret ballot made it impossible to determine where the additional votes came from.
Hoppermann said an earlier internal vote in the CDU parliamentary group had resulted in abstentions or votes against Rausch. She said it would be up to the state parliamentary groups to determine whether and how the secret ballot could be clarified.
Catarina dos Santos-Wintz, the Union’s parliamentary manager in the Bundestag, said possible CDU members who deviated from the group position should consider how they could reconcile their decision with their conscience. She did not call for consequences such as expulsion from the parliamentary group.
She also ruled out CDU support for AfD politician Ulrich Siegmund in the December minister-president election in Saxony Anhalt, saying she was relying on the state parliamentary groups and the state party to ensure this would not happen.
SPD leader and Vice Chancellor Lars Klingbeil said Rausch’s significantly higher vote total raised “very pressing questions”. He said both the BSW and CDU needed to explain how the result had occurred.
Klingbeil described the election as a “taboo breach” and criticised the election of another AfD politician, Hans-Thomas Tillschneider, as deputy president. SPD candidate Armin Willingmann, meanwhile, failed to win the deputy president position. Klingbeil described the developments as showing “unprecedented irresponsibility and a lack of historical awareness”.
He said the SPD would continue opposing right-wing extremism through democratic means and stand with those in Saxony Anhalt supporting an open and democratic society and opposing exclusion and racism.
The AfD, which the Saxony Anhalt Office for the Protection of the Constitution classifies as definitely right-wing extremist, won the state election on 6 September and holds 39 seats, three short of an absolute majority. Rausch’s election has left the source of the four votes beyond the AfD and BSW’s combined parliamentary strength unresolved.