Germany’s Bundesrat (Federal Council) has temporarily blocked the government’s planned Equal Opportunities and Quality Development Act for early childhood education. By a clear majority, the federal states voted on Friday in Berlin to refer the legislation to the Mediation Committee.
During the debate, several states strongly criticised the federal government for planning to reduce its financial support for childcare while simultaneously transferring additional responsibilities to the states, particularly in the area of language development. Federal Education Minister Karin Prien (CDU) called for a compromise.
Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania’s Minister-President Manuela Schwesig (SPD) said it was goof that the federal government would continue providing funding for daycare centres. She also welcomed the planned assessment of language skills among children attending daycare centres. However, she said the price for this must not be that "funding for early childhood education dries up".
"If the federal government introduces new responsibilities, it must also contribute to financing them," said Berlin Education Senator Katharina Günther-Wünsch (CDU). She pointed out that the federal states were already investing considerable amounts in improving the quality of childcare.
"The law needs to be revised," demanded Saarland Education Minister Christine Streichert-Clivot (SPD). "Anyone expecting higher standards must also take responsibility for financing them," she said, addressing the federal government.
"Education does not come free of charge," said North Rhine-Westphalia Family Minister Verena Schäffer (Greens). "The federal government cannot impose new and additional standards on us while withdrawing from funding." She stressed that quality standards and funding could only be considered together.
Prien expressed her willingness to compromise. However, she emphasised that "the implementation of childcare services is fundamentally a responsibility of the federal states and municipalities, including their financing".
Nevertheless, the minister said the federal government remained willing to take on financial responsibility. Prien urged the parties to work towards an agreement quickly through the Mediation Committee.
She also pointed out that the federal government had already made concessions to the states on several key issues during the legislative process. For example, the proposed standards for general staffing levels had been removed from the legislation.
The Bundestag (German parliament) passed the so-called Equal Opportunities and Quality Development Act last week. Under the legislation, all children aged four and above would have their developmental progress assessed in several areas.
A particular focus would be placed on language development. The assessments would also cover children's social-emotional and motor development, as well as their mathematical abilities. Daycare centres with particularly high numbers of children facing challenging living circumstances are set to receive additional staff.
However, the legislation also provides for a gradual reduction in the federal government's financial contribution to childcare funding. Around €1.5 billion is planned for each of the years 2027 and 2028. This will fall to €1.24 billion in 2029, followed by annual funding of €993 million from then on. Federal government funding is scheduled to end completely in 2034.