Sunshades under large trees, expensive toilets with hardly any visitors and unused laptops: In its latest Black Book, the German Taxpayers’ Association (Bund der Steuerzahler) has once again documented 100 examples of public money being wasted and project costs escalating. The association said on Thursday that, particularly in economically difficult times, it was “all the more” important to take a close look at how public funds were being spent. It criticised poor planning as well as projects where the relationship between costs and benefits was not justified.
The city of Stuttgart was among those featured in this year’s Black Book. The city spent €350,000 on sun sails and parasols, including some placed underneath a huge plane tree. In Schleswig-Holstein, teachers received almost 35,000 new laptops. However, around one-third of the devices were never switched on. The Taxpayers’ Association criticised what it described as the waste of “€6.7 million in taxpayers’ money on unused technology.”
The association also questioned a flood-protection project in Hesse, where the small town of Neu-Anspach planted just five trees as part of an elaborate specialist planting project costing €100,000. It also criticised seven new benches in Hamburg costing €14,800. The benches were installed along a steep and heavily trafficked road. “Rest breaks including noise and exhaust fumes,” the association commented, “if at all, because some of the benches are crooked.”
The Taxpayers’ Association also proposed abandoning some specific projects altogether in order to prevent public money from being wasted in the first place. These include the planned 2035 State Garden Show in Schwerin, which the association described as an “€83 million project with a considerable risk of losses,” as well as plans for a government airport at Berlin Brandenburg Airport (BER). “Several hundred million can ultimately turn into as much as €2.5 billion.”
Every year, the Taxpayers’ Association publishes 100 representative cases of public money being wasted at the municipal, state and federal levels. Once again, association president Reiner Holznagel appealed to those responsible to “rethink structures, do without what is unnecessary and permanently reduce bureaucracy.”
This year’s Black Book also includes a special chapter examining the risks associated with funding programmes through which the federal government, Germany’s states and the EU provide financially struggling municipalities with money for specific projects.
According to the association, problems can arise when high funding rates make projects appear attractive and funds are drawn down simply because otherwise they would expire. “It has fatal consequences when spending is not consistently decided according to need, economic efficiency and impact,” Holznagel warned.
The association cited, among other examples, the construction of a toilet facility in the Hessian town of Hadamar at a cost of €355,700. The toilets are expected to be used for only a few days each year, while the funding for the project would have expired at the end of 2026.
The association also criticised the financially struggling state of Saarland for planning to replace its green cycle-path signs with the familiar white signs. The project is expected to cost €2.2 million and uses funding programmes financed primarily by the federal government. According to the association, cheaper alternatives had been “rejected.”
In light of tight public finances, Holznagel therefore called on the federal government and Germany’s states to set time limits for their funding programmes and coordinate them more effectively. He also called for the programmes to be reviewed regularly and for those with “poor effectiveness” to be discontinued.