German Chancellor Friedrich Merz has firmly ruled out any peace settlement for Ukraine that is negotiated over the heads of European nations. Speaking on Thursday after hosting a Ukraine summit at the Chancellery in Berlin, the CDU leader warned that “a Yalta format will not bring peace”, invoking the 1945 conference at which the victorious Allied powers of World War II set in motion the division of Europe into two opposing blocs.
The historical comparison was prompted by a three-way meeting held the same day in Shenzhen, China, where US President Donald Trump, Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese leader Xi Jinping held talks on a range of international issues. Although the gathering was widely described as historic, Merz played down its significance, remarking that the Shenzhen meeting had “apparently been above all a photo opportunity.”
The Yalta Conference, held in Crimea from February 4 to 11, 1945, brought together US President Franklin D. Roosevelt, British Prime Minister Winston Churchill and Soviet leader Joseph Stalin to plan the post-war order. The three leaders confirmed the division of Germany into occupation zones, set a date for the conference that would found the United Nations and agreed on new borders for Poland.
Only the American, British and Soviet delegations took part, and countries whose futures were decided there, Poland among them, were not represented. The meeting has since become shorthand for major powers settling the fate of others without them at the table.
According to the Chancellor, any future peace negotiations must bring together Ukraine, Russia, the United States and Europe. “If they come about, that opens up the best chance for peace so far,” he said. Europe’s side would be represented jointly by Germany, France, the United Kingdom, Poland and Italy, together with the institutions of the European Union. The leaders of these five countries, known as the E5, all took part in the Berlin discussions.
Merz also welcomed Washington’s efforts to open fresh negotiations with Moscow. “The US knows there is no peace without us. We know that with the United States at our side, the chances of peace increase,” he said. He added that European, Ukrainian and American advisers were set to reconvene at the Chancellery later on Thursday evening for further talks.
The Chancellor insisted that the current line of contact between Russian and Ukrainian forces must serve as “the starting point for a territorial understanding.” Ukraine, he said, must remain free to pursue its European path and should receive support in rebuilding the country. In return, he signalled that a “gradual, conditional lifting of sanctions against Russia” could be considered. Once a ceasefire is in place, Kyiv must be given “strong security guarantees,” Merz stressed.
Merz laid out a clear order of priorities: “First peace in Ukraine, then agreements on Euro-Atlantic security.” He said Moscow was aware that the “maximalist demands of December 2021” it had put forward were not realistic. At the appropriate time, however, talks with Russia would also need to address military communication channels, risk reduction and transparency.
The Chancellor also pointed to the heavy price Russia is paying on the front line. According to Merz, Russian forces “lost more than 50,000 soldiers” in October alone, a figure he said was roughly what American forces lost in total over almost two decades of the Vietnam War. “That is how much Russia loses in a single month. Russia must therefore understand that it is time to lay down its arms,” he said.
Merz further referred to recent Ukrainian attacks on the Kerch Bridge, which links the Russian mainland to the Crimean peninsula annexed by Moscow. “The fact that Ukraine has severely damaged the Kerch Bridge, once again last night, is a clear warning and also a clear sign of Russia’s weakness,” he said.
Russian authorities reported that the bridge came under Ukrainian attack during the nights leading into both Monday and Wednesday, forcing repeated suspensions of traffic across the strategically important crossing. Addressing the Kremlin directly, Merz said: “Today we say to President Putin: end the war in Ukraine and let us search together for diplomatic solutions.”
The Berlin meeting of the so-called Coalition of the Willing brought together 26 heads of state and government to discuss ways of bringing the war to an end. According to the German government, a total of 45 delegations took part.
Among those present were US negotiators Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, French President Emmanuel Macron, British Prime Minister Andy Burnham, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni and Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk. European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte also attended.
According to government sources in Berlin, the timing of the Coalition of the Willing meeting was deliberately aligned with the Putin-Trump-Xi summit in Shenzhen, allowing European leaders to respond directly to developments there.