German politicians across the political spectrum responded on Wednesday to the outcome of the US midterm elections, in which the Democrats won back majorities in both the House of Representatives and the Senate, previously held by President Donald Trump's Republicans. Their reactions ranged from congratulations and hopes for a policy shift to warnings that Trump's foreign policy could become even less predictable.
Speaking at the Berlin Security Conference, Defence Minister Boris Pistorius (SPD) congratulated the Democrats on what he called a historic victory in both chambers of Congress. Germany would continue to seek close contact with the Democrats, as it has in the past, he said, describing this as a matter of course.
At the same time, Pistorius stressed that Germany would continue working in a spirit of trust with the US administration, which remains unchanged and has two more years in office. What to expect from Washington now depends partly on the president's plans after the election, he said, adding that this is not yet known.
Germany has dealt with such uncertainty for years, he noted, and will respond in its proven way: staying on course and living up to its responsibilities, regardless of election results.
CDU foreign policy expert Jürgen Hardt said he hopes for a more sensible US foreign policy. Speaking on ARD's "Morgenmagazin", he argued that the result should be read as criticism of Trump's approach to Iran, Israel and Russia, three issues he believes contributed to the outcome.
Hardt said he was counting on Trump to act more reasonably, not least with future elections in mind. His advice to the Republicans was to recognise the result as a judgement on the president's misguided foreign policy. He pointed to a contradiction: Trump had originally claimed he had no interest in foreign affairs and that the military was not a tool for solving conflicts, yet he has deployed troops abroad perhaps more than previous presidents. In Hardt's view, this contradiction has partly come back to haunt him.
Fellow CDU foreign policy expert Peter Beyer took a different view. He told the "Rheinische Post" that Trump's room for manoeuvre in foreign policy is limited and that he does not expect a change of course in Washington. According to the former transatlantic coordinator, voters' wallets decided the election.
High living costs are Trump's political weak spot, he said, and the president's central promise to make life more affordable for Americans has failed. Beyer called the result a wake-up call for the Republicans, saying MAGA alone cannot win majorities, while the Democrats must now show they can do more than beat Trump.
Green parliamentary group leader Katharina Dröge welcomed the result as a signal of hope well beyond America's borders. After Brazil, Serbia and Hungary, she told AFP, it is further proof that authoritarian forces can lose elections and an inspiration to people worldwide. She described the outcome as great news for American democracy and a crushing defeat for Trump, citing his poor economic policy, job losses and soaring prices as key reasons voters turned against him.
Dröge warned, however, that Trump remains a risk, as his foreign policy is likely to grow more erratic and dangerous in the coming years. Europe must not be naive and should keep investing in its own security and sovereignty, she said, calling on Chancellor Friedrich Merz (CDU) to act as a counterweight by championing an alliance of states committed to fair global rules.
The AfD responded to the Republican defeat by cautiously distancing itself from Trump. Markus Frohnmaier, foreign policy spokesman of the AfD parliamentary group, told AFP there were clear differences over issues such as tariffs and Iran, while stressing broad ideological common ground with the Republicans on defending national and cultural identity, keeping out migration and opposition to left-wing ideologies.
He added that Trump's administration still governs and shapes foreign policy, and that the transatlantic partnership must continue on the basis of a shared Western civilisation.
Party leader Alice Weidel told t-online that Trump broke his promise to avoid an interventionist foreign policy by attacking Iran, and attributed the scale of the defeat mainly to the devastating consequences of the Iran war.
Parliamentary manager Bernd Baumann told the "Handelsblatt" that Trump had made unnecessary mistakes, pointing to import tariffs that fuelled inflation and the ongoing Iran conflict, including the blockade of the Strait of Hormuz, which drove up energy prices. Baumann nonetheless emphasised the AfD's continued ideological closeness to Trump, saying voters had elected him to end the dominance of a "woke establishment".