Shortly after a draft for the planned sugar tax became public, the Federal Chancellery has put the brakes on the proposal. The draft from the Federal Ministry of Finance is “no longer capable of securing a majority in the government in this form,” government sources said on Thursday. The draft, from the office of Federal Finance Minister Lars Klingbeil (SPD), was made public on Wednesday and triggered harsh criticism from the beverage industry and employee representatives.
“For the introduction of a sugar tax, the proposal of the Financial Commission on Health is the agreed basis,” government sources said. The proposal from the Finance Ministry deviates from that basis. Klingbeil’s ministry, however, said that the federal government had decided to introduce a tax on sugar-sweetened beverages. “The discussions on how this will be specifically implemented are currently under way,” the ministry said.
The coalition government of the CDU/CSU and SPD had agreed to introduce a sugar tax from 2027 as part of negotiations over the cost-cutting package for statutory health insurance.
A commission appointed by the government had recommended a tiered sugar levy. For beverages containing five grams of sugar or more per 100 millilitres, around 26 cents per litre would be charged. For beverages containing eight grams or more, manufacturers would pay 32 cents per litre. According to the commission, this would generate around €450 million in annual revenue from 2028 onwards.
The Finance Ministry draft that became public on Wednesday, and which was obtained by AFP, proposed a different system. It would have introduced a tax of 32 cents per litre for beverages containing seven grams of sugar or more per 100 millilitres, and 38 cents per litre for beverages containing ten grams or more. The tax was due to come into force on 1 July 2027. According to the draft legislation, it would generate €1.155 billion in additional revenue from 2028. The ministry expected additional revenue of €1.18 billion in 2031.
The proposal triggered strong criticism from the beverage industry and employee representatives. “Under the draft legislation, the annual tax revenues are several times higher than what the Financial Commission on Health proposed and what the Federal Cabinet decided,” the German Brewers’ Association (DBB) said. The Food, Beverages and Catering Union (NGG) called for a demonstration outside the Federal Ministry of Finance in Berlin on 8 October.
The German Association of Non-Alcoholic Beverages (Wafg) said that implementing the tax on 1 July next year was “completely unrealistic.” Wafg Managing Director Detlef Groß welcomed the fact that the plans for the sugar tax would “first be carefully reconsidered.” “The proposal would inevitably lead to significantly higher consumer prices,” he said.
“At the same time, it goes far beyond the proposals of the Financial Commission on Health in terms of the tax rates themselves and reaches into consumers’ pockets.” The Finance Ministry would also have to answer the question of “whether it has correctly understood the coalition agreement’s objective of reducing bureaucracy,” Groß said.
There was also resistance from within the Union parties. “I am stunned and extremely irritated,” Caroline Bosbach (CDU), the Union’s rapporteur on the Agriculture Committee, told the Tagesspiegel. The proposal appeared “almost like a provocation,” she said. Bosbach added that she was “glad that the Chancellery has pulled the emergency brake.”
The process used by the Finance Ministry to circulate the draft also appears to have caused tensions within the coalition. According to information from Bild, the ministries involved were given “only 24 hours from Monday evening” to assess the legislation and send requests for changes to Finance Minister Klingbeil.
Because an email containing the legislation was sent only to staff at the working level, the draft reportedly reached “many of the top decision-makers, such as ministers and state secretaries,” only a day later.
Proposals from the Federal Ministry of Finance had already caused confusion in August. According to those proposals, beverages sweetened with artificial sweeteners, such as Coke Zero, were also supposed to be covered by the tax. Federal Finance Minister Lars Klingbeil (SPD) subsequently clarified that sugar-free beverages would not be taxed.
Support for the tax has come from consumer organisations such as Foodwatch, as well as medical associations including the Marburger Bund and the German Medical Association. “While the coalition is arguing, the sugar lobby is celebrating – and children’s health is suffering,” Foodwatch representative Luise Molling said on Thursday.
“The current draft legislation implements the proposal of the Financial Commission on Health almost one-to-one and would be a milestone in the fight against diet-related diseases,” she said. The soft-drinks tax has broad public support, Molling added. “Anyone who blocks it now is dancing to the tune of the sugar lobby.”