Economists have once again sharply criticised Germany’s fuel tax cut as the latest fuel discount comes into effect. “Just as last time, it is unclear how much of the tax reduction will actually be passed on to end consumers,” economic adviser Veronika Grimm told the Augsburger Allgemeine on Thursday. She also said the costs of the relief package were higher than they might appear at first glance.
“First, the money has to be raised and is then missing elsewhere for investment or other future-oriented spending,” Grimm explained. She called it “cynical” that politicians were now subsidising driving cars with combustion engines at the expense of the younger generation, arguing that the federal budget is financed by debt to the extent of 30 percent.
Grimm also criticised what she described as a focus on short-term measures rather than overdue reforms aimed at generating greater economic growth. “This is likely to mean a greater loss of prosperity for citizens than temporarily higher fuel prices,” Grimm told the newspaper. “Through this opportunistic policy, an attempt is being made not to alienate voters, but in the end it will only lead to many voters becoming frustrated and turning away from the established parties.”
Ifo President Clemens Fuest criticised the measure as unfair. “The fuel discount results in redistribution in favour of frequent drivers with large cars,” he told the Augsburger Allgemeine. Many of them, he said, are people who can afford the high prices. If politicians want to provide relief to specific groups, such as commuters, they should instead use targeted instruments, Fuest said, citing measures such as increasing the commuter tax allowance and making direct payments to lower-income households.
The Ecological Transport Club VCD criticised what it called the government’s “wrong priorities”, also pointing to the higher price of the Deutschlandticket from 2027.“High costs, little impact: The fuel discount is an expensive blanket solution,” said VCD Chairwoman Christiane Rohleder. “For around €2.5 billion in taxpayers’ money, the costs for motorists will fall by an average of less than €40 through the end of the year — that is what real relief looks like.” At the same time, she said, climate-friendly mobility by bus and train was becoming more expensive.
The fuel discount came into effect on Thursday. Until December 31, the tax rates on petrol and diesel will each be reduced by around 17 cents per litre. The measure will cost the state €2.5 billion. This is already the second fuel tax cut of the year. In May and June, taxes on fuels were also reduced by around 17 cents per litre.
Evaluations of the first fuel tax cut found that the reduction was largely passed on to consumers at petrol stations. However, according to the Monopolies Commission, just over €200 million of the previous relief package, which amounted to €1.6 billion, remained with mineral oil companies.