Germany’s planned reform of emergency medical care is set to take effect after the Bundesrat approved the legislation by a majority on Friday in Berlin, despite concerns raised by several federal states.
The central aim of the reform is to ensure that hospital emergency departments primarily treat patients who genuinely require emergency care. Patients whose conditions can be handled by a doctor’s practice or another outpatient service should instead be directed there, reducing unnecessary pressure on emergency rooms, ambulance services and medical staff.
At present, emergency departments and rescue services are frequently used for cases that could be treated in regular medical practices.
A key factor in securing the states’ support was a last-minute protocol declaration from the federal government addressing several of their concerns and promising changes to the legislation.
Federal Health Minister Carsten Linnemann (CDU), who presented the declaration to the Bundesrat, said the states would receive a greater say in determining the locations of ambulance stations and emergency care centres.
The government also clarified that financing would cover not only the operation and availability of these facilities but also necessary investment costs. Following these commitments, a majority of Germany’s federal states dropped their earlier threat to refer the legislation to the Mediation Committee.
Linnemann described the emergency care reform as a “milestone”, arguing that Germany’s various medical services would become better connected. Until now, he said, they had too often operated alongside one another rather than as part of an integrated system.
According to the minister, the reform should create a system that works more effectively for all sides while putting patients’ needs at its centre.
A major component of the reform is the establishment of so-called Integrated Emergency Centres, or INZ, at hospital locations.
Patients arriving at these centres will first undergo a medical assessment. Depending on the urgency of their condition, they can then be directed to a cooperating doctor’s practice, an out-of-hours medical service or directly to the hospital emergency department.
The government also wants patients to be directed to the appropriate medical service before they arrive at a hospital whenever possible.To achieve this, Germany’s non-emergency medical assistance number, 116117, is to be expanded and more closely connected with the 112 emergency number.
The intention is to create a more coordinated system in which callers can be assessed and guided towards the service most appropriate for their medical needs.
Several state governments backed the legislation after receiving additional assurances from Berlin.
Rhineland-Palatinate Interior Minister Achim Schwickert (CDU) said his state wanted the emergency care reform to move forward and therefore decided not to pursue mediation.
Brandenburg Health Minister René Wilke (SPD) described the decision as a “vote of confidence” in the federal government, while Hesse Health Minister Diana Stolz (CDU) stressed that the states must be able to rely on the commitments contained in the protocol declaration.
However, a minority of states continued to call for the legislation to be referred to the Mediation Committee. Lower Saxony Health Minister Andreas Philippi (SPD) argued that what ultimately mattered was not a declaration of intent but what was actually written into the law.
He also criticised the arbitration procedure planned for disputes over the locations of emergency facilities and the influence health insurance funds would have over investment projects.
Saarland Health Minister Magnus Jung (SPD) similarly expressed reservations about last-minute changes introduced shortly before the Bundesrat vote.
The Bundesrat also adopted a supplementary resolution raising concerns about provisions allowing emergency centres to dispense medicines directly to patients. The states warned that this could have negative consequences for pharmacies.
Meanwhile, German Medical Association President Klaus Reinhardt welcomed the restructuring but cautioned that its effectiveness would only become clear once the changes were implemented in practice.
He stressed that the reform must consistently reduce the burden on emergency departments and ambulance services by keeping cases that do not require emergency treatment out of the system. The planned pathways guiding patients to the appropriate care provider should therefore be made more binding, he said.
Germany’s AOK Federal Association also welcomed the legislation, describing reform of emergency care as long overdue.
AOK chairwoman Carola Reimann said that although the law does not address every issue consistently, it could finally provide patients with a more structured and understandable route into Germany’s acute and emergency healthcare system.
The German Red Cross (DRK) also welcomed the federal government’s protocol declaration but called for a long-term solution to funding emergency medical services.
DRK Secretary General Christian Reuter warned that a reform that fails to reliably finance the permanent availability of rescue services risks undermining its own objective of providing fast, high-quality emergency care across Germany.
He called on the federal government, the states and health insurance funds to agree on a sustainable financing model.
The reform is intended to fundamentally change how patients access emergency treatment in Germany. If successfully implemented, the combination of Integrated Emergency Centres, improved telephone assessment and closer coordination between 116117 and 112 could help ensure that patients receive the right treatment while reducing pressure on overcrowded hospital emergency departments.