Following former Federal Constitutional Court President Hans-Jürgen Papier, the Left Party has also spoken out in favor of lowering the threshold clause for Bundestag elections. Ina Latendorf, the Left Party's parliamentary secretary, told the Rheinische Post on Thursday: "It has to be seen critically that many voters' choices ultimately go unconsidered because of the five-percent hurdle."
Günter Krings (CDU), deputy leader of the Union parliamentary group, rejected lowering the five-percent hurdle. "We should keep our hands off it," he told the Redaktionsnetzwerk Deutschland (RND).
The debate was set off by the former President of the Federal Constitutional Court, Papier. In a Tagesspiegel interview earlier this week, he called the five-percent hurdle "no longer in keeping with the times." The legal scholar advocated lowering the threshold clause for Bundestag elections from five to three percent.
Papier said that in the 2025 Bundestag election, 6.8 million of 49.6 million valid second votes "fell by the wayside" because they went to parties that won less than five percent. A vital democracy, he added, also depends on new parties being able to emerge. "With the five-percent hurdle, it is very difficult to found, build up and sustain a party. That leads to the risk of political ossification." More parties in parliament meant "more democracy, not less."
Under Germany's Federal Election Act, a party must win five percent of the second votes nationwide to be included in the allocation of Bundestag seats. If a party wins fewer votes, it does not enter parliament. Parties representing national minorities, and parties that win at least three direct constituency seats, are exempt from the five-percent threshold clause.
Left Party politician Latendorf said the threshold clause means the will of voters is "not represented in the best possible way, which should, however, be the goal in a democracy." Her party therefore supports Papier's proposal to lower the threshold to three percent. "An electoral law reform along the lines of his proposal would not fail because of us."
Union parliamentary group deputy leader Krings, on the other hand, emphasized: "Especially in times like these, we need more stability in parliamentary work, not less." Lowering the tried-and-tested five-percent hurdle would make already difficult government formations even harder, he told the RND newspapers. "It could also create an incentive for party splits and the founding of new parties."
Saxony-Anhalt's SPD lead candidate, Armin Willingmann, had also spoken out in favor of lowering the threshold clause. A new state parliament will be elected in Saxony-Anhalt on September 6. The SPD is at risk of failing to clear the hurdle to enter the state parliament there. The AfD is leading the polls by a wide margin.