Hesse’s state government has launched a renewed effort to make denying Israel’s right to exist a criminal offence. The state says it has been supported in its initiative by a new legal opinion, which was presented in Berlin on Monday. The legal opinion “clearly refuted” the constitutional concerns raised by the federal government, Hesse’s Justice Minister Christian Heinz (CDU) said at the presentation.
At Hesse’s initiative, the Bundesrat, Germany’s upper house of parliament, already set a legislative proposal in motion in early July aimed at criminalising the denial of Israel’s right to exist. The proposal would add a new subsection to Section 130 of the German Criminal Code, which deals with incitement to hatred.
Under the proposal, anyone who publicly or at a gathering denies the right of the State of Israel to exist or calls for its elimination would be liable to punishment. However, such conduct would only be punishable “if it occurs in a manner that promotes a willingness to engage in antisemitic acts of violence or arbitrary acts”. The proposed penalty would be imprisonment for up to five years or a fine.
The federal government can submit its position on the Bundesrat’s legislative proposal. The Bundestag, Germany’s lower house of parliament, would then take up the matter. There are no statutory requirements specifying when the Bundestag must debate the proposal submitted by the states.
Hesse’s state government has now called on the federal government to ensure that the Bundestag reaches a decision on the Hessian proposal and to recommend approving it. The proposal is “a signal to all Jewish people in our country: The state is not looking away. We stand by your side,” Hesse’s Minister-President Boris Rhein (CDU) said.
Constitutional law expert Steffen Augsberg, who authored the new legal opinion, considers the Hessian proposal a “very good, constitutionally valid basis”. He said that concerns raised against the proposal did not go far enough. Freedom of expression is certainly a fundamental right, he said, “but it was deliberately not made absolute”.
It may instead be necessary to restrict freedom of expression, Augsberg emphasised. “Such a case exists here,” he said. However, he stressed that an important element was the provision in the proposed law that only “criticism that has the potential to produce violence” should be prohibited.
Hesse’s Justice Minister Heinz explained that the main aim of the legislative proposal was not to punish individuals simply for shouting such slogans. Instead, the primary purpose was to give authorities the legal means to prohibit relevant gatherings or impose conditions on them.
Josef Schuster, president of the Central Council of Jews in Germany, welcomed Hesse’s initiative but questioned whether Section 130 of the Criminal Code “is really the right place for a legal provision”. At its core, he said, the issue concerns calling for the destruction of another state, which should be addressed in the section of the law dealing with offences against foreign states. Schuster called for a legally sound reform of criminal law.