A price increase for electricity and gas despite a provider’s price guarantee is unlawful. The Higher Regional Court of Hamm (OLG Hamm) ruled this on Monday. According to the court, all price increases imposed by Extraenergie on September 1, November 1 and December 1, 2022, were invalid. Affected customers are therefore entitled to the originally agreed price. (Case No. 2 VKl 2/23)
The Federation of German Consumer Organisations (Verbraucherzentrale Bundesverband, vzbv) filed the lawsuit. Affected customers were able to join the association’s model declaratory action until mid-July 2026. If the ruling becomes legally binding, affected customers who registered in the official claims register maintained by the Federal Office of Justice can demand refunds.
Extraenergie GmbH, which operates providers including Extraenergie, Extragrün, Hitenergie and Prioenergie, significantly increased its gas and electricity prices in 2022. According to consumer protection advocates, prices in some cases rose by more than 200 percent, despite existing price guarantees. The company justified the increases by referring to an “unprecedented 840 percent increase in electricity prices.”
The Higher Regional Court of Hamm ruled that Extraenergie GmbH was not permitted to increase its electricity and gas prices in autumn 2022 through unilateral letters sent to its customers. Customers who had paid the higher prices had done so “without legal grounds to the extent of the price increases,” the court stated. The originally agreed price therefore remains applicable to those customers.
The court also rejected the company’s argument that it could rely on a disruption of the contractual basis under the German Civil Code. By guaranteeing a fixed price, the company had also accepted the risk of even substantial price increases, the court found.
The court explained that the business model had specifically been designed to attract customers or prevent them from switching to other energy providers. The company therefore could not pass those price increases on to precisely those customers in violation of the agreed fixed-price arrangement. “The profit that the defendant may have sought to generate by offering fixed-price agreements was linked to the obligation to assume the resulting procurement risks.”
“This ruling shows that collective actions ensure that consumer protection reaches people,” said vzbv Chairwoman Ramona Pop. The Higher Regional Court had confirmed the consumer organisation’s position that Extraenergie’s enormous price increases were unlawful. “Now a swift reimbursement is warranted,” Pop said.