Deutsche Bahn (DB) has scored a legal victory in its dispute over the planned entry of Italian competitor Italo into the German long-distance rail market. On Thursday, the Administrative Court of Cologne ruled in an urgent decision that a competition clause for long-distance routes with capacity limits was unlawful. The court also rejected a requirement that competitors be offered space at railway stations for lounges.
In July, the Federal Network Agency had ordered Deutsche Bahn’s infrastructure subsidiary, DB InfraGO, to make room for competitors on heavily congested long-distance routes. The competition clause was intended to apply to the preparation of the 2028 rail network timetable. From that year, Italo plans to operate long-distance services on the heavily used and therefore particularly profitable routes from Munich via Cologne to Dortmund and from Munich to Berlin.
Long-distance rail travel in Germany is currently dominated by Deutsche Bahn. In principle, other companies are able to offer long-distance services as well. DB InfraGO prepares the rail network timetables on an annual basis.
Italo has planned substantial investments and had called for multi-year framework agreements to provide the planning certainty needed for those investments. However, the Federal Network Agency rejected this request and instead imposed the competition clause.
DB InfraGO subsequently took legal action against the Federal Network Agency’s decision. In August, the company said the order carried “considerable legal and practical risks for capacity management”. It also said the measure would worsen “the structural problem of bottlenecks and capacity”.
Deutsche Bahn also criticised the Network Agency’s requirements concerning the allocation of space at railway stations to new competitors for ticket counters and lounges. The Cologne court has now ruled that neither national nor European law provides a basis for requiring such a competition clause.
“Moreover, the clause is unsuitable for achieving the purpose pursued with it,” the court said. It criticised the measure for being too limited to encourage investment. “No investment decision will be made dependent on the existence of the competitor clause.”
The court also rejected the requirement to treat railway station lounges “as service facilities and to include corresponding access regulations in their terms of use”. According to the court, the services provided in railway station lounges were not “related to railway operations”. The Federal Network Agency therefore had no jurisdiction over them.
The Administrative Court of Cologne stressed that it was not specifically ruling on the market entry of any individual company. “The subject matter was solely the question of the legality of the specific competitor clause, which was rejected due to the lack of a legal basis and its unsuitability,” the court stated. The decision cannot be appealed.