Germany's Federal Court of Justice (BGH) has declared Amazon's 2022 Prime price increase invalid, ruling that the clauses used to justify it were not transparent enough. The decision, issued in Karlsruhe on Thursday under case number III ZR 205/25, is a victory for the Consumer Advice Centre of North Rhine-Westphalia (Verbraucherzentrale NRW), which brought the lawsuit.
In July 2022, Amazon informed its German customers, numbering in the millions according to consumer advocates, that Prime would become more expensive. From September 15, 2022, the monthly fee went up from €7.99 to €8.99, while the annual membership climbed from €69 to €89.90.
The consumer protection group challenged the increase and won at both the Düsseldorf Regional Court and the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf. The BGH has now upheld the appeals court's decision. The federal judges found that Amazon violated the transparency requirement, and that allowing the price adjustment to stand would put customers at an unreasonable disadvantage.
Although Amazon said it disagrees with the verdict, a company spokesperson announced on Thursday evening that the Prime fee will be temporarily adjusted for certain members. The reduction applies to customers whose membership began before September 15, 2022 and has remained unchanged ever since.
The BGH ruling did not cover fees that customers have already paid. Amazon's spokesperson noted that this matter is the subject of separate proceedings. The Verbraucherzentrale NRW has filed a class action to recover possible overpayments on behalf of affected customers, and that case is still pending before the Higher Regional Court of Hamm.
The consumer protection organisation described the outcome as an important success for consumers. Board member Wolfgang Schuldzinski said the court has now made it clear that a price adjustment clause is not a free pass for companies to raise prices as they please.